Nano Blog & Social Media Hop: Unfollow Period

The Unfollow Period:

We now enter the optional two-week Unfollow Period of the Nano Blog & Social Media Hop, which is from Monday, December 19, to Sunday, January 1, 2016. For certain sections of the Hop, the instructions below are to download free apps that make unfollowing easy; for other sections, I have taken painstaking efforts to present you with the links of the participants who are least likely to have followed you back. That way, you only have to check a small number of links as opposed to going through all of the links in the original Nano Hop post. This doesn’t mean these people didn’t follow you, so please double check if they are following you before unfollowing them. These links will disappear after the Unfollow Period. If you see your link, and you believe I included it here in error, no problem, just let me know.

After this email, I will only use this list A) to announce the prize winners in January; and B) if you are in the Facebook Hop which is moved to the New Year.

First, I owe everyone crazy thanks for taking a leap of faith, trusting that I could make the Nano Hop as successful as possible. It’s hard for me to say what the ultimate rate of full participation was, but I think we’re darn close to 85% in terms of partial participation. I had aimed for 80% full participation, but having no way to track that, I’m guessing we landed closer to 60%. Important to note is that many non-participants joined in and started following everyone’s accounts, and as the blog will remain posted, more followers will continue to trickle in. It’s to your benefit to follow these authors back. (And before you ask, no, I will not make changes to your links. There are too many of you, and I need to get back to writing my book!) We were never going to get to 100% participation, because I only asked people to participate in good faith. If I were to do it over, I would ask for a stronger commitment before people signed up, and put in place checks and balances, but hindsight and all that. It’s up to each of you to decide for yourselves if your participation in the Nano Hop experiment was worth your while. Was the follower increase you saw large enough for the amount of time put in? Are you seeing increased engagement now that people are starting to recognize your name? If you answered yes to both, then I hazard the time put in was worth it, and I’ll accept social media and blog love for life as payment. 😉 If you said no to both, then I owe you social media love for life. Well, let’s say I do either way. 🙂

Immediately below are your Unfollow Instructions and below that are 3 articles I hand selected on how to retain your new audience.

Unfollow Instructions:

Below are instructions, for each section of the Hop, on how to as easily as possible unfollow those who didn’t return your follow. But before we get to that, I’d like to say, “Don’t”, “Why bother?”, “What’s the rush?” and “Save yourself some time.” Here’s why:

  1. Some participants got a late start and are still in the process of following you. For this reason, you may at least want to hold off on unfollowing for about a week. Put a note in your calendar to come back to this email.
  2. All things considered, do you really care if your profiles are padded with a few extra non-followers? For certain accounts, I do, but in reality, I’m not as active, for instance, on Pinterest right now, and I couldn’t be bothered to do the work to clear out my non-followers.
  3. People are far more likely to follow people that look like they follow back. If your following count is slightly higher than your follower count, I personally am more likely to follow you. I’m not saying you should never clear out your non-followers. I’m saying there’s no need to rush, and it could be to your benefit not to.
  4. Also, the people who didn’t participate may have had countless reasons for doing so. Life could have gotten in the way, they may have been confused or overwhelmed by the technological side of things, or despite my attempts to avoid ending up in junk mail, they may not have received a single email from me. And here’s the big one. They may have signed up for the Nano Hop and changed their minds when they realized what was involved. Should I have explained things more to people at the signup level? Yes, but I was still putting it together and didn’t know how it was all going to work. Should they have messaged me and bowed out when the Hop started so as to not waste anyone’s time? Probably. But it doesn’t mean they had malicious intentions to collect hundreds of follows without reciprocating.

Without further ado, here are the unfollow instructions, should you wish to use them. If you know of an easier way than my suggested methods, please explain in the comments, and I will adjust these instructions as necessary. Important to note: I never recommend mass unfollowing or maintaining a low following count. It will hurt you in the long run, because as more and more people become familiar with unfollow tools, they will unfollow you. In essence, you will slowly bleed your following, so it isn’t worth it.

Twitter: You could click on each Twitter link and check to see if each profile has followed you back, however, you will save oodles of time if you instead download an app that will sort your unfollowers into a section where you can select which ones you want to unfollow. Search your app store for “twitter unfollow,” and you will find many reliable paid and unpaid options to choose from no matter what type of phone you have. I used the unpaid versions of both of my apps for a long time, until I realized that as my following grew, I needed to purchase the paid options to make my life easier. I don’t ever recommend using a mass unfollow tool. It may seem easier, but using them can get your account deleted from Twitter. Instead, it’s best to use a tool that lets you unfollow no more than 100 profiles a day. I can only give you an app recommendation for iPhone, because I can’t trial apps for other types of devices: Unfollow for Twitter by Spicy Apps. Once you download this or any other app on your phone, it will load your unfollowers into a section called “Don’t follow back” or something similar. Again, be careful about unfollowing more than 100 users a day. Twitter frowns on this type of activity.

Facebook: Because Facebook blocked many of us from liking pages and deleted our recent page likes (we were doing it too fast even though none of my pre-research indicated this would happen), I have moved the Facebook portion of the Hop to the New Year, and because of steps I have taken, we will have a near 100% participation rate. If you didn’t read the email, you can find the plan here: You don’t need to unfollow anyone during the Unfollow Period. Wait for an email from me in the New Year.

Instagram: This is the same rant as Twitter but with a free app recommendation for Instagram that I’ve just started using and like. This app is for iPhone, but again, you can easily find lots of free apps in any app store by searching “Instagram unfollow.” My recommendation is Followers for Instagram by No Apostroph3s.

Goodreads: Step 1: Go to your profile page, click on the icon of silhouettes of people in the top right-hand corner, then, in your right sidebar at the top click on People You Are Following. For each person that says “Friend request pending” click cancel friend request for them all (…if you want to. They’re just outstanding friend requests and so it isn’t essential to cancel them.) Step 2: I explained in the Nano Hop post that there are two types of accounts, and I asked you to take two steps with the Author Accounts. I asked you to both friend and follow authors. Below are the links of 7 authors who are least likely to have friended you back, and while it isn’t necessary to cancel friend requests, you can certainly unfollow them should you wish to do so. You can either save yourself some time and just check the 7 links below or you can check all authors by clicking on “Authors You’re Following” on the same screen near the top. Then right click/open each name, and look under their “Following” button. If it says you are friends, no action is required. If it says nothing, click “Following” to unfollow them. Or again, you could just do the same for the 7 links below.

Links no longer available.

Google+: The most efficient way to do this was removed from circulation last week, so my big plan for you to easily find those who didn’t follow you back went up in smoke the moment Circloscope decided to shut its operations. My opinion is that the shutdown is part of a larger Google+ strategy to avoid runaway follower increases through management tools. If you already have this Chrome extension, then use it, but if not, there is currently nothing on the market to make your life easy. Instead, I’ve pulled the list of people who are least likely to have followed you back. Go to your profile, and in the left column, click “People”, then click “Followers” in the top menu. Search your followers for each of the following 23 names, and if they don’t appear, you can choose to unfollow them.

Links no longer available.

Tumblr: Similar to what Google+ is doing, Yahoo has virtually shut down the ability to track your Tumblr unfollowers, and I’m pretty sure this happened recently according to the complaints I’ve read. You can’t even compare followers to people you are following easily. I’ve checked numerous free apps. To save you time, FriendorUnfollow has a free trial but requires permission to follow accounts on your behalf, and the Google Chrome extension that used to aid in managing Tumblr followers was recently changed to no longer include this feature. There are a couple of technologically intense ways to export lists for comparison that even I don’t want to attempt, as well as a couple of very expensive tools that are probably owned by Tumblr. Instead, here are 21 the links that are least likely to have followed you back. Go to your follower list in Tumblr, and if they aren’t following you, you can choose to unfollow them.

 Links no longer available.

Scribophile: There are only 19 people in this section of the Hop, but Scribophile also does not make it easy to find out who isn’t following you. I’ve compared my own followers/people I’m following and come up with five links who may not have followed you back. To save you from having to check all 19 people, you’ll save time if you click only on the five links below, scroll down and click on their “Favorites” on the left. If you’re not in their favorites, you can choose to unfollow them.

Links no longer available.

Scriggler: I don’t have Scriggler, but there are only 6 participants in this section of the Hop, so if you would like to check if they returned your follow, here are their links.

Wattpad: Wattpad doesn’t make it easy to compare followers to those you are following, so I have done the comparison for myself, and here are the links of the people who are most likely to not have followed you back. Instead of checking all 59 participants, you can save time by only having to open the 17 links below. Click on each one, then on the left on the sidebar, click “following”, scroll through, and if you aren’t in the list of people they are following, you can choose to unfollow them by clicking the “Following” button in the sidebar on the right. Remember, just because they didn’t follow me back doesn’t mean they didn’t follow you.

 Links no longer available.

YouTube: YouTube only shows you your subscribers who allow their subscriptions to be public. Here’s the math. I had zero subscribers before the Hop. There were 42 participants. 19 people followed me in the past week, but I can only see 9 of them, because the others have privacy settings preventing me from seeing them. I can’t advise unfollowing anyone, because it is near impossible to determine whether or not they followed you. This one person withdrew their YouTube page from the Hop in the first week, so if you followed them, it is unlikely they followed you back.

Link no longer available.

Pinterest: The only free Pinterest unfollow tools on the market at the moment are ones that come with catches that make them untrustworthy, or they’re a scam. Don’t add any of them. The easiest way to unfollow non-followers on Pinterest is demonstrated in this 14-minute video that I personally am not going to bother with.

Blogs/Websites: First, let me apologize. This was the most difficult section of the Hop to get everyone to participate in. If I were to go back to the planning stages of the Nano Hop, I wouldn’t include it, but I did, and now I’m faced with presenting you with an option to easily unfollow those who didn’t follow you back. The problems are that we’re dealing with multiple website platforms, and there are two types of subscriptions:

  1. Reader/RSS Subscriptions: For instance, for blogs, to compare reader subscriptions to find unfollowers, you can check the list of blogs you are following here against your follower list, which can be found at the bottom of your stats page. But if you are on a platform other than, you’ll have to check your settings to determine how to do this. If you’re wondering if the effort is worth the time, that’s up to you. I wound up with a lot of RSS/reader subscriptions, so I’m not really worried about it.
  2. Email Subscriptions: I have struggled with what to do here, because it’s a logistical nightmare. Some people were following back with RSS/reader subscriptions, and it’s not up to me to decide if that’s fair. I should have asked for the email address people were going to sign up with, but I didn’t, and so now there is no way for any of us to check if the person returned our follow. You can deduce what blog/website most of them belong to but not all. Instead of unfollowing anyone, my suggestion is evaluate the quality of the emails you receive from authors over the next while. If the quality is not up to your standards, then unsubscribe. This was never a commitment to continue following authors beyond the life of this Hop. This was always about giving each other a follower boost, and after that, it’s up to each of us to provide content that will keep people following. That’s why I’ve hand selected three articles on the topic of how to keep your following below.

3 Hand-selected Articles on Audience Retention:

Why Posting Everyday is a Silly Strategy and What to Do Instead: This blogger outlines the three way in which blogging too often can hurt your brand and lower your subscriber count.

The Art of Self Promotion on Social Media: Want to make sure people don’t have a reason to unfollow you? Learn about the different ratios that marketers use to balance self promotion with value-added content.

11 Common Blogging Mistakes that Waste Your Audience’s Time: Self explanatory.

Thank you for participating in the Nano Blog & Social Media Hop. You’re all awesome!

23 thoughts on “Nano Blog & Social Media Hop: Unfollow Period

  1. Thank you for all your hard work! I thought it was a great success. I know I nudged a few people who hadn’t followed me back to do so and the ones that didn’t got the unfollow already. I gained about 300 Hop tweeters and many many more non hop authors through it. You spent so much time on this & I thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I do believe some people are waiting for others to follow them first instead of being proactive. This will, no doubt, result in at least 20% or so of participates not realizing the full potential of this exercise.
    Publishers are interested in an author’s social media platform and if your plan is to self-publish it is even more important to have a solid presence to get the word out about your work. We will get out of it what we put in to it. Thank you for all your hard work,Raimey, it is greatly appreciated!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thank you, Raimey! Because of your hard work, my blog went from 30 to about 100 followers! It remains to be seen whether those new followers will stay and engage with me, but I’m thrilled. This was definitely a worthwhile exercise. I got to build my platform and check out what other authors are doing to build theirs.

    Liked by 3 people

  4. I have loved everything about this, i have gained a lot of traction in the three areas I signed up for, met some really interesting people, read their work on Wattpad, and just I don’t know, feel so much more like I’m a part of a community. You have given us a wonderful gift, and I really do think you have helped to make my world a better place. Thank you. You are incredible for doing this.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Raimey, I appreciate everything you’ve done for the Nano Hop. Your hard work and generous aid are amazing! I’ve seen increased in my social media sites, and after going through a snag, I’ve gotten through it.
    Thanks so much for all you’ve done!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Thanks again for organizing all of this, Raimey! This finally pushed my twitter numbers over the 2k mark after having plateaued for oh… a year at about 1600 – talk about an awesome feeling!

    I’m glad you’re still leaving the master list up as I’m definitely one of the people who’s way behind – I’ve focused on Twitter & Instagram for now, but I still have FB & blog follows to do for sure.

    As far as my name under google+, I legitimately never use it, so people can definitely unfollow me there! I don’t even know how to tell if they did follow me there LOL

    But yeah, thank you thank you this was awesome!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Wow. What a useful, content-filled post. The Nano Hop has been a useful experience that gave me a kick in the pants when it came to social media, and this post is no exception. Thank you so much for everything you have done. I know it was all a lot of work.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I’ll add my voice to the chorus of thanks…it really has been wonderful to meet some new people and feel more like I am part of a writing tribe. I fully expect the benefits to be more evident over time, so I’m not planning on unfollowing. So many wonderful blog posts to read and books to be added to my “want to read” list on Goodreads. The holidays are a challenge, as we travel around the country every year for three weeks visiting family and friends. Very intermittent access to Wifi, so I will be catching up in January!
    All blessings to you for a happy, healthy, prosperous and productive New Year in 2017!
    Thanks again!

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I think you did a great job! This was a ton of work – I don’t know how you did it! I’ve definitely noticed an increase in followers, and it’s been a blast visiting so many blogs and author pages – perfect way for a newbie author to connect with more established authors, and just awesome people. So, thank you!

    I have to say too, I totally forgot I had a Wattpad! I must have put my link in to that when I signed up, but I completely forgot about that account! I skipped over that section in the sign-up lists because I didn’t think I had one. Now I feel bad. :/ Going to go see if I can follow the people who have followed me on there, because that is another platform I’d like to start using more next year.

    Anywho, thank you so much for organizing this! I wish Goodreads wouldn’t limit the daily friend requests – I haven’t been able to get all the way through the list yet! Going to keep adding everyone until I reach the bottom though! haha

    Thanks again, and best of luck in your writing! =D

    ~Roze Wallin

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Thank you for all the effort that you put into Nano hop: I hope that your own writing hasn’t suffered too much in the process!

    I followed everyone in Twitter and blogs/websites, and I probably won’t unfollow people at all. It took a lot of time to follow websites in the first place, and there are so many interesting pages. I am sure that some people are behind in blog following anyway, and need a chance to catch up in follow backs!

    I’m just excited to have more followers, so thank you again for arranging this 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  11. As others have said, you are owed a huge thanks for all the work that you put into this. I personally have gained a number of twitter and blog followers and have tried to follow everyone back too. One thing I found helpful was to use the list feature on Twitter too. I created a list with all the NaNoHoppers and probably a few other people that followed during that period as well.
    The other outcome of all this is the boost it gave me in my confidence to really pursue my writing full-time. Because I’m engaging more with other writers, new readers, and others in general, I’m putting more of my writing out there and gaining valuable feedback. It’s a learning experience for us all.

    Liked by 1 person

  12. I wanted to thank you as well. (I also can’t imagine the amount of work you put into this, because it took me a huge amount of time just to get through the Twitter and Blog Post links!) Not only did I gain a big chunk of new Twitter, author page, and GoodReads followers, I also learned a lot from this experience. For one thing, my author page had a sign up button that was impossible to figure out (I’ve hopefully improved it some), and I have a much better idea of blog content and how to send out subscriber emails. Baby steps, I know, but it’s been a great learning experience and I can’t thank you enough!


  13. Thanks for all your hard work organizing this Hop! My blog began with 28 followers and now I have about 90. I hope my content is engaging enough to keep them as we go forward. So My Twitter grew by 200 followers and my Instagram grew by over 100. I’m getting to know lots of fellow writers and having fun! Thank you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s